the heart is not a pie chart

unspeakable
Writers as entertaining, vulnerable, and clever as Meghan Daum are rare, and  a tome of essays that tickle the wit and heart like The Unspeakable: And Other Subjects of Discussion is a fine treat for a train ride. Daum starts out unapologetically from the first page with a description of her mother dying while the writer was distracted by an article in Vogue—and doesn’t let up from there. I read it in a single afternoon while on VIA Rail traveling from Vancouver to Jasper.

Her essays run the gamut from slightly sickening (“Matricide”) to name-dropping (“The Joni Mitchell Problem” and “Invisible City”) to altruistic (“Difference Maker”) and oddly heart-rending (“Not What it Used to Be”, and frankly, all of the above). In turns confessional and self-objective, she ponders and challenges ideas about sentimentality and authenticity. Her intro posits: “We like the idea that everything happens for a reason. When confronted with the suggestion that life is random or that suffering is not always transcendent we’re apt not only to accuse the suggester of rudeness but also pity him for his negative worldview.” As she goes on, she discovers that the sentiment of the everyday can only be spoken about “in coded terms”—things like maybe not loving your parents enough, or thinking that the most enjoyable parts of life feel like chores are rarely talked about, if at all.

“It’s about the unspeakable acts that teach no easy lessons and are therefore elbowed out of sight.” I loved The Unspeakable about as much as I did Daum’s 2015 release, Selfish, Shallow, and Self-Absorbed: Sixteen Writers on the Decision Not to Have Kids (more on that title some other time).

Best bits: Daum’s coming to terms with not wanting children, despite her husband’s aptitude and desire for fatherhood. It made me sob. Alone. In a traincar bathroom.

The charades game at Nora Ephron’s house is hilarious, as is an incredibly awkward moment for Nicole Kidman.

Finally, her ongoing shuffle between femininity and butchness described in “Honorary Dyke” is an anthem for tomboys and femme-friends alike.

 

Blood, Bones, and Butter

Blood Bones ButterGabrielle Hamilton’s Blood, Bones and Butter: The Inadvertent Education of a Reluctant Chef is near perfect, in my mind, when it comes to food-writing and memoir. This has so many things I love in a book, but mainly that it’s by a smart, ferocious lady who has a tendency to associate love with eating.

The sections of the book—how family weirdness shapes us as young people (Blood), how food experiences settle in the psyche (Bones), and how these things combine to form the dysfunctional and/or successful adults we become (Butter)—are introduced with a fervent honesty and frankness that is at times surprising.

Hamilton is a kitchen boss at heart, musing on her torpid personal life while building New York’s Prune to be the well-loved, eclectic institution it has been for the past 15 years—now cemented as one of the city’s favourite brunches (the service for which Hamilton affectionately refers to as “a shitshow”). There’s wicked candour in descriptions about her personal relationships, and an unapologetic tinge that could make those with overtly traditional ideas about marriage a bit squirmy. One friend thought the book was “kinda sad”, another described it as “hilarious and frustrating.”

Best bits: Off the top, there’s the slightly surreal and drool-inducing set-up in describing her father’s famed annual party, complete with full pig roast and performance artist roster. Next is the simple, intoxicating egg and toast she receives from her Greek host while traveling alone as a not-quite adult; this is a formative moment in her path to becoming a chef. Finally, her endearing love for her Italian mother-in-law, who does not speak English, but is an unexpected source of strength and softness for the otherwise hardened Hamilton. It’s the Nona bits that fuel the waterworks for me.

resolutions

After a few requests from friends on the “what I’m reading” front, I am going to start the habit of posting book recommendations here. Be warned: I tend toward nonfiction (new and old), female writers, literary journalism, and dark humour. Also classic sci-fi. The Russians tend to pop up, too. Oh, who am I kidding? I read anything.

Tharp HabitFirst up in 2016—and to celebrate this new habit of mine—I’m recommending Twyla Tharp’s The Creative Habit . Tharp is one of the past century’s most prolific and well-known choreographers, has worked with countless other (quite famous) artists and creators, and has a penchant for no-nonsense creative practice. She followed The Creative Habit up with The Collaborative Habit in 2009, and now at 74 years of age, continues to create dance today.

Best parts: The comfort of Ritual in daily work, the one-box-per-project approach, and the incredible crash-course on American dance history that she shares—somewhat incidentally—while detailing her own habits, projects, and collaborations. She talks about how her Billy Joel show, Movin’ Out, was challenged by early reviews of preview performances (the gall!), her work on Amadeus with Miloš Forman, and a life’s worth of tidbits from working with Martha Graham, Merce Cunningham, and Paul Taylor.  It’s a behind-the-process peek for the dance aficionado, and a worthy treatise on just how to keep the creative juices flowing for 50+ years.